Will Shetterly has an interesting post about boing boing’s handling of comments and something called (god help us all) “disemvoweling.”
“Xeni owes BB’s readers a new post so the readers who fell for this hoax will know the truth.”
“If you have any respect for AI, please make a new post to let all BB readers know the truth.”
Avram Grumer explained at #257, “Will, I’ve partially disemvoweled your cts #246 and 248. Do not presume to tell Xeni (or the other Boingers) what to post about.”
disemvoweling and the law: copyright, fair use, and defamation « it’s all one thing
Shetterly’s a bit of a crank, and his comment style is even a bit trollish, but he has interesting things to say, and in this case, he’s brought to my attention this thing called disemvoweling. Which has to be among the stupidest things ever to emerge from the reeking bowels of the internet.
Per Wikipedia:
In the fields of Internet discussion and forum moderation, disemvoweling (also spelled disemvowelling), which appears to model the word disemboweling, is the removal of vowels from text either as a method of self-censorship, or as a technique by forum moderators and newsgroup operators to censor unwanted posting….
Regarding the use of disemvoweling to police internet blog comment sections, Xeni Jardin, co-editor of Boing Boing, says of the practice, “the dialogue stays, but the misanthrope looks ridiculous, and the emotional sting is neutralized.”
That is spectacularly stupid. If someone is being a misanthrope in your comments, they already look ridiculous. Removing the vowels from their comment makes you look ridiculous.
Shetterly takes the whole thing a bit far down the legal road, to well past the absurdity mark, but he does have a valid point. If a comment bothers you, delete it, dmbss.