I’m pretty pleased with ??Heroes??, although it is easily one of the most derivative things I’ve ever seen. It’s not always fair to say, “Oh, that’s just X-Men,” because the X-Men mythos is pretty damn broad, and it’s certainly not as though the idea of a mutant-powered genetically different subset of the population began with X-Men; Alfred Bester certainly has them by decades, and I doubt he can claim to be the originator.
But in the case of this show, it’s hard to avoid feeling not just that one is watching a big-budget tv version of X-Men, but that one is watching a big-budget tv version of ??Mutant X??, the syndicated action series which could not (owing to Sony’s acquisition of the movie rights) speak its name, as it were.
But that’s okay; I enjoyed ??Mutant X??.
The other obvious derivation is ??Unbreakable??, which many, many, many people hated, but which I thought was terrific. ??Heroes?? combines the hero-everyman dichotomy of ??Unbreakable?? with the global perspective and conspiracy subplot of ??Mutant X??. One wonders, in fact, if this wasn’t part of the pitch, in the combinatorial hollywood fashion. (??Kiss Kiss, Bang Bang?? fans, all together now: “Native American Joe Pesci.”)
I find it very difficult to be impressed by this combination, but I also find it very easy to be entertained by it. Good enough.
Some of the characters do, however, break through to a deeper level of interest. The suicidal cheerleader is certainly refreshing (not everyone who wants to kill him/herself is a goth, and not every super-hero cheerleader is Buffy Summers — not that she didn’t have her suicidal moments, as I recall), and the little Japanese guy kicks ass. I’m also intrigued by alternate persona stripper person; I like the idea of a superhero with a power which could only possibly be at home in a horror film — although her character seems a bit cookie-cutter in other respects.
Now, the actual writing, in contrast to the character creation, so far is strictly okay, but hopefully that will pick up as time passes. ??Heroes?? is run by Tim Kring of ??Crossing Jordan??, and while that hasn’t necessarily been a groundbreaking show, it has strong plotting and dialogue, which hopefully will be true of ??Heroes?? as well. And hopefully ??Heroes?? won’t fall victim to the mid-season loss of momentum that contributed to the downfall of ??Surface?? and ??Invasion?? last season…. luckily, I didn’t catch the first episode until it re-ran last night, so it has a fair chance of avoiding the much-weakened Nick’s Law curse.
(I know no one liked ??Surface?? and not that many people liked ??Invasion??, but both had extremely strong season season endings, and it bothered me a lot that neither returned.)